Clayface beats Supergirl score James Gunn calls it a pleasure
The DC Universe is currently navigating a fascinating creative landscape, where some experiments are scoring high, and others are grappling with the realities of the box office. This contrast is perfectly illustrated by the performance of the recent DC films, specifically the visceral body horror of Clayface versus the hopeful, yet challenging, debut of Supergirl.
The deeper dive into the macabre offered by Clayface has garnered significant critical acclaim. The film landed a score of 76% on Rotten Tomatoes, demonstrating a deep psychological resonance that many critics felt successfully connected with the material. Reviewers noted that the film achieved a level of emotional depth and resonance that allowed it to stand alongside masters of the body horror genre like David Cronenberg and Sam Raimi.
However, the critical reaction to Clayface included a measured note on its narrative. While the visual and thematic elements were outstanding, some felt the script occasionally struggled to fully support the unsettling subject matter, leading to a nuanced verdict that balanced the spectacle with a somewhat ‘so-so’ storyline.
In stark contrast, Supergirl faced a more difficult journey, achieving a Rotten Tomatoes score of 52%. Despite being the second film in the DC Universe, the film did not meet the expectations set for the franchise’s launch. Its global box office gross of $126.4 million highlighted the gap between creative vision and commercial performance.
Despite the box office outcome, DC Studios co-CEO Peter Safran remained confident in the long-term strategy for Supergirl. He reflected that the film was just one component of a broader, enduring plan, suggesting that the focus is on building a larger universe rather than immediate financial success.
Behind these different results, the creative team appears to have found a unique space. Director James Watkins shared that he felt a freedom to explore the story of Clayface without the mandate to align with a ‘greater universe,’ emphasizing that the project felt right as a standalone story.
This atmosphere of creative autonomy seems to be a cornerstone of the current DC Studios approach. As the franchise continues to expand, the focus is clearly shifting toward trusting the unique voices and visions that define each cinematic experience, whether they are exploring the depths of body horror or the soaring potential of a new heroine.
With Clayface hitting theaters on October 23, audiences are invited to experience that psychological depth, while the broader DCU continues its ambitious quest for cinematic success.
Credit
