Miyazaki: You can’t make anything fun by following rules
In the world of video games, the pursuit of ‘fun’ often clashes with the strict adherence to established rules. Hidetaka Miyazaki, the visionary force behind FromSoftware, recently offered a fascinating take on this dichotomy, arguing that simply replicating a formula across every title doesn’t guarantee enjoyment.
The lineage of FromSoftware is undeniable. Games like Dark Souls have inspired a massive mountain of titles, carving out a unique and impactful niche in the gaming industry. Yet, Miyazaki points out that the success of FromSoftware lies not in following a rigid set of rules, but in using those foundations to build something entirely new.
He acknowledges the studio’s undeniable house style—the shared mechanics found in franchises like Assassin’s Creed or the long-standing focus on cinematic third-person action. However, this consistency is a tool, not a cage. Miyazaki emphasizes that playing titles like Sekiro and Elden Ring back-to-back proves that the studio actively avoids mere repetition, ensuring that each game feels distinct.
This commitment to originality is central to how FromSoftware creates its beloved experiences. When developing a new title, the focus is placed on identifying what is inherently interesting to the team first, using that discovery as the guide rather than a strict philosophical mandate.
The recent development of The Duskbloods offers a perfect case study for this philosophy. While the core combat systems of games like Bloodborne are compelling, Miyazaki cautions that injecting new gameplay loops, such as incorporating multiplayer or extraction shooter elements, must be handled with extreme care.
He notes that if developers adhere too strictly to a set of rules and philosophies without creative flair, the result can quickly become stale and conservative. The challenge, therefore, is finding the sweet spot: honoring the core identity while introducing fresh mechanics that genuinely enhance the experience.
Ultimately, FromSoftware’s success seems rooted in a careful balance. They leverage a proven aesthetic while continually pushing boundaries. This strategic approach allows them to evolve their world, ensuring that every new game feels like an exciting departure rather than just another iteration of a familiar formula.
Buy on Amazon
Credit
